I'm a new member, still working my way through the first 5 lessons. Really enjoying the site thus far. As a Phish fan, this is pretty much the first song any girl (who you are trying to woo with your guitar) is going to ask you to play. Plus, it's a good song . And, your site needs some Phish!
Some youtubes in case you are not familiar with the song:
1) Phish's version
Trey is a guitar god, so probably not the easiest way to play the song (but I'll let you tell us). I know that stretching the pinky out there can't be easy.
2) Dave Matthews has a cool acoustic way to play it
I noticed that he is not using a pick, and then grabs a pick of the mic during the main chorus. Same song, different style.
3) Finally, some fan versions that I found.
Both show the fingering clearly. The 2nd guy has some really nice fills.